Summary
- What is a Benefit in Kind?
- What is changing with Benefits in Kind?
- What changes day to day?
- Why is Benefits in Kind a data problem, not just a payroll one?
- What should recruitment agencies watch for with agency workers?
- Taxable or not? Examples from the webinar
- Watch our experts talk through it
- How do you get ready for April 2027?
- Download the Benefits in Kind Readiness Checklist
- Map your payroll flow
What is a Benefit in Kind?
A Benefit in Kind is a non-cash benefit from an employer that has a taxable value. Think company cars, fuel, medical cover, vans, loans or accommodation. While employees don't receive these benefits as cash, HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) may treat their value as taxable income, and employers may also have Class 1A National Insurance obligations.
What is changing with Benefits in Kind?
From April 2027, the first phase of mandatory payrolling begins. Company cars, company fuel, vans, van fuel and employer-provided medical benefits will move into payroll reporting. A second phase is expected from April 2028, bringing most remaining taxable benefits into mandatory payrolling.
| Today (2026/27) | April 2027 (Phase 1) | April 2028 (Phase 2) | |
| What's covered | Most BIKs | Company cars and fuel, vans and fuel, employer-provided medical benefits | Most remaining taxable benefits, such as taxable subscriptions and certain vouchers |
| How it's reported | After the year ends, on P11Ds | Income Tax and Class 1A NIC through payroll, in real time | Through payroll, as in Phase 1 |
| Still on a P11D? | Yes, for most benefits | Yes, for benefits outside Phase 1 | Only for benefits outside mandatory payrolling, currently loans and accommodation |
The phasing is good news. HMRC is bringing this in two steps, rather than moving most benefits across in one go in April 2027. P11Ds aren't disappearing overnight either. They stay for the benefits that can't be mandatorily payrolled.
As Emily James put it:
April 2027 is the first milestone, but it's not the finish line. Employers need to prepare for both phases now.
What changes day to day?
Quite a lot. You currently have time after the tax year to find, reconcile and correct benefit data. From April 2027, that data has to be accurate and available during the year. Payroll and benefits reporting can no longer run as fairly separate processes, because Finance, HR and Payroll need to work together in real time. And an error or a late update could directly change an employee's monthly net pay, rather than being tidied up at year end.
One more thing worth knowing. You can payroll some benefits before they become mandatory, but you'll need to apply to HMRC first. Don't assume you can start payrolling Phase 2 benefits without approval, as HMRC may still expect them to be reported on a P11D.
Why is Benefits in Kind a data problem, not just a payroll one?
One message came up repeatedly throughout the webinar:
Payroll cannot report what it doesn't know.
Emily was clear that the software isn't the sticking point:
The question simply isn't whether your payroll software can process a benefit, it's whether you can get complete and accurate information into payroll at the right time.
Her suggestion is to be able to answer five questions for every benefit: who receives it, how its taxable value is determined, where the underlying information sits, who is responsible for that information, and how it is reported today.
Then think about how changes reach payroll during the year. Joiners and leavers, changes to medical cover, a change of vehicle or the date a car became available, annual renewals. Each of those data feeds should pass four simple tests.
- Complete: do you know about every benefit provided?
- Timely: does payroll hear about changes before cut-off?
- Clear ownership: does someone provide and check it?
- Reconcilable: can Finance, HR and Payroll confirm that what was reported is correct?
What should recruitment agencies watch for with agency workers?
Agencies may be responsible for payroll and employment tax compliance for workers who receive benefits, expenses or facilities from an end client. That raises two separate questions. First, is what the worker receives actually a taxable benefit? Second, if it is, who reports it and accounts for PAYE and National Insurance?
Not everything provided to a worker is taxable. Safety equipment, qualifying work-related travel and certain transport arrangements may be exempt. But something provided for perfectly good operational reasons can still be taxable. The test is the nature of the provision:
The tax treatment really depends on the nature of the provision, not who pays for it.
It is something Emily hears a lot:
I hear a lot of clients saying, well, the end client provided it, so we don't need to worry about it. That won't wash, unfortunately, with HMRC.
The responsible party might be the agency, the agency worker or the end client. Don't assume it. Establish it.
Taxable or not? Examples from the webinar
Emily worked through four situations that agencies meet all the time.
- A minibus to a 6am shift. Not necessarily taxable. A qualifying works bus service is allowed for home-to-work journeys, but the minibus needs at least nine seats, and the service must be available to employees generally and used mainly for qualifying journeys. Paying someone's commuting costs is a different thing.
- Mileage for a six-week assignment. Taxable, and it should go through payroll. Under the employment intermediaries legislation, where the conditions are met, each assignment counts as a separate employment for travel and subsistence. A worker supervised by the end client who travels to the same warehouse each day is making ordinary commuting journeys, even on a short assignment.
- Hard hats, hi-vis and safety boots from the end client. Generally not taxable. They are genuine protective equipment, and the end client providing them doesn't change that. Ordinary clothing such as jeans or trainers is different. If workers have to buy their own PPE and aren't reimbursed, it can also reduce their pay for National Minimum Wage purposes.
- Free lunches in the end client's canteen. Generally not taxable. A specific exemption covers qualifying workplace canteen meals, but check the circumstances rather than assuming free food is always exempt.
Watch our experts talk through it
This article covers the headlines. Want the full picture? In 45 minutes, Emily James of Menzies LLP covers the two phases, benefits provided by end clients and getting data to payroll on time. Then she takes your questions, from P11Ds to accommodation.
How do you get ready for April 2027? Five steps
The webinar boiled preparation down to five steps: Identify, Assess, Establish responsibility, Test, Prepare. And a gentle nudge on step one. Even if you did this for your P11Ds this year, do it again:
...you might feel like you've already done it once this year. I would suggest you do it again.
- Identify what people actually receive. List everything provided to employees and agency workers, including anything from end clients. Start from what the business provides today, not just last year's P11Ds.
- Assess the treatment. Decide whether each item is taxable, exempt, earnings or a reimbursed expense, and record why.
- Establish responsibility. For each item, confirm who provides it, who reports it and who supplies the data. Agree the data process with each end client.
- Test. Map the flow from end client to agency to payroll. Run sample employees with different benefits through the process and reconcile the results to your existing records.
- Prepare. Confirm payroll capability, agree client processes and build a plan across Finance, HR and Payroll, with owners and dates.
Emily was emphatic about step four:
Test, test, test. I should have put it there three times.
Next step: Download the Benefits in Kind Readiness Checklist
With mandatory Benefits in Kind (BiK) reporting on the horizon, now is the ideal time for recruitment agencies to review how payroll, finance, HR and operations data flows through the business.
For many agencies, Benefits in Kind data sits across multiple systems and teams, making reporting more complex than it first appears. Mapping these processes early can help uncover data gaps, clarify ownership and avoid last-minute compliance risks before the April 2027 deadline.
If you're responsible for payroll, finance, HR or compliance, our Benefits in Kind Readiness Checklist provides a practical starting point. It will help you:
- Identify all Benefits in Kind across your organisation
- Review tax treatment
- Map data ownership
- Test reporting processes
- Build an action plan before April 2027
Map your payroll flow
Recruitment agencies often have complex pay and bill processes involving temporary workers, contractors, commissions and multiple payroll touchpoints. Understanding how Benefits in Kind data moves through these workflows now can make future reporting significantly easier.
Talk to Access about mapping your current pay and bill process and identifying any gaps before the reporting changes come into effect.
AU & NZ
SG
MY
US
IE